Part I · Chapter 3

Complex inputs

's step was to let ss be a . This chapter says why he did it, what 1/ns1/n^{s} means when ss is complex, and why the sum still converges when the of ss is greater than 1.

Why Riemann wanted complex ss

In 1859 Riemann wrote one short paper on number theory, "On the Number of Primes Less Than a Given Magnitude". had an approximation for the number of up to xx (chapter 1). Riemann wanted an exact formula.

The link between ζ\zeta and the primes at the end of chapter 2 can be written as an :

−ζ′(s)ζ(s)  =  s∫1∞ψ(x) x−s−1 dx-\frac{\zeta^{\prime}(s)}{\zeta(s)} \;=\; s\int_{1}^{\infty} \psi(x)\, x^{-s-1}\, dx

This gives a function of ss in terms of the prime-counting function ψ\psi. Riemann wanted the reverse: ψ\psi in terms of ζ\zeta. The integral is a transform of the same kind as the and Laplace transforms, and the formula that inverts such a transform is an integral over complex values of ss. So to solve for the primes, ζ\zeta has to be understood as a function of a complex variable. Riemann was the leading expert of his time on such functions, and he carried the inversion through.

Complex numbers in three facts

What 1/ns1/n^{s} means

Write s=σ+its = \sigma + it, with σ\sigma the real part and tt the imaginary part. Since n=eln⁡nn = e^{\ln n},

n−s  =  e−sln⁡n  =  n−σ⋅e−itln⁡nn^{-s} \;=\; e^{-s\ln n} \;=\; n^{-\sigma}\cdot e^{-it\ln n} This is a vector of length n−σn^{-\sigma}, at the angle −tln⁡n-t \ln n.

The real part σ\sigma sets the length, exactly as for real ss. The imaginary part tt does not change the length at all. It only turns the vector, and it turns the vector for a large nn further than the vector for a small nn.

Lab 3.1 one term, n−s, as a vector
the vector n−sthe unit circle
Horizontal axis: real part. Vertical axis: imaginary part. Moving σ\sigma changes only the length. Moving tt only rotates the vector, clockwise, at a speed proportional to ln⁡n\ln n. For n=1n = 1 nothing moves: 1−s=11^{-s} = 1.

Adding the vectors

For complex ss the definition is the same sum, ζ(s)=∑n−s\zeta(s) = \sum n^{-s}. Complex numbers are added by placing the vectors head to tail. The sum of the first NN terms is where the chain of NN vectors ends.

The total length of the chain is ∑n−σ\sum n^{-\sigma}, which is the real sum of chapter 2 and is finite when σ>1\sigma \gt 1. A chain of finite total length must close in on a single point. So:

For every complex ss with real part σ>1\sigma \gt 1, the sum converges, and its value ζ(s)\zeta(s) is a complex number. Euler's product also holds there, so ζ(s)≠0\zeta(s) \ne 0 for σ>1\sigma \gt 1.

Lab 3.2 the first N vectors of ζ(s), placed head to tail
the chain of vectors● the end of the chain● ζ(s)
The chain starts at the origin with the vector for n=1n = 1, which is always 1. Later vectors are shorter and turned further, so the chain spirals in toward the solid dot.

Things to try

  • In Lab 3.1, set n=2n = 2 and raise tt slowly from 0. The vector completes one full turn when tln⁡2=2πt \ln 2 = 2\pi, at t≈9.06t \approx 9.06.
  • Keep tt fixed and step nn through 2, 3, 4, 5. Each vector is a little shorter and turned a little further.
  • In Lab 3.2, set t=0t = 0. All the vectors point to the right and the chain is the real sum of chapter 2.
  • Lower σ\sigma toward 1.05 with t=8t = 8. The spiral takes many more vectors to tighten, and the end of the chain stays visibly away from the white dot.

Exercises

  1. Compute 2−s2^{-s} for s=1+iπ/ln⁡2s = 1 + i\pi/\ln 2.
    Solution

    The length is 2−1=122^{-1} = \tfrac12 and the angle is −tln⁡2=−π-t \ln 2 = -\pi, a half turn. So 2−s=12⋅e−iπ=−122^{-s} = \tfrac12 \cdot e^{-i\pi} = -\tfrac12.

  2. Show that ∣n−s∣=n−σ|n^{-s}| = n^{-\sigma}, whatever tt is.
    Solution

    n−s=n−σ⋅e−itln⁡nn^{-s} = n^{-\sigma} \cdot e^{-it \ln n}, and ∣eiθ∣=cos⁡2θ+sin⁡2θ=1|e^{i\theta}| = \sqrt{\cos^{2} \theta + \sin^{2} \theta} = 1 for every real θ\theta.

  3. The chain for s=2+5is = 2 + 5i has what total length?
    Solution

    The lengths are n−2n^{-2}, so the total is ζ(2)=π2/6≈1.645\zeta(2) = \pi^{2}/6 \approx 1.645. The chain ends at ζ(2+5i)\zeta(2 + 5i), which is at most that far from the origin, since a chain cannot end further away than its own length.

Check your understanding

  1. In s=σ+its = \sigma + it, what does changing tt do to the term n−sn^{-s}?

    • It changes the length of the vector
    • Nothing
    • It rotates the vector without changing its length, and rotates vectors with larger nn faster

    The angle is −tln⁡n-t \ln n and the length is n−σn^{-\sigma}. All the difference between real and complex ss is in how the vectors are turned relative to each other.

  2. Why does the sum converge for every tt once σ>1\sigma \gt 1?

    • The chain of vectors has finite total length ∑n−σ\sum n^{-\sigma}, and turning the vectors cannot make it longer
    • Because the vectors cancel each other
    • Because tt is small

    Convergence here does not depend on cancellation. When σ≤1\sigma \le 1 the total length is infinite, and whether the chain settles then depends entirely on the turning.

  3. Why did Riemann need complex ss at all, when the primes and the sum are real?

    • Because primes are complex numbers
    • −ζ′/ζ-\zeta'/\zeta is an integral transform of the prime-counting function, and the formula that inverts such a transform integrates over complex ss
    • To make the sum converge faster

    The same happens with the Fourier transform: a real signal is recovered from its transform by integrating over frequencies with complex exponentials.