Part II · Chapter 13 needs review

Summing over whole numbers

Chapter 12 summed a function over the powers of γ\gamma, and the factor 1−γ−s1 - \gamma^{-s} appeared in front of its . Summing over the whole numbers instead puts ζ(s)\zeta(s) in front. The resulting functions are the of the paper.

Based on §1.1.4 of the paper (page 12), read in full. The lab works over the ordinary integers with the trivial character, which is the case; the paper works over any .

θ-functions

The paper uses the construction of chapter 12 with a different sum, the one at the center of . Take a function ff on (0,∞)(0, \infty) and sum its values at all whole-number multiples of xx:

Θf(x)  =  x ∑n≥1f(nx)\Theta_f(x) \;=\; \sqrt{x}\,\sum_{n\ge 1} f(nx) The paper calls functions of this form θ-functions. The transform is M(Θf)(s)  =  ζ ⁣(s+12)⋅M(f) ⁣(s+12)M(\Theta_f)(s) \;=\; \zeta\!\left(s+\tfrac12\right)\cdot M(f)\!\left(s+\tfrac12\right)

Proof: by the rescaling property the transform of f(nx)f(nx) is n−s⋅M(f)(s)n^{-s} \cdot M(f)(s), and ∑n−s=ζ(s)\sum n^{-s} = \zeta(s). Multiplying by x\sqrt{x} replaces ss by s+12s + \tfrac12. (The sum converges for Re⁡s>12\operatorname{Re} s \gt \tfrac12; the identity extends to all ss by when Θf\Theta_f decays at both ends.) The factor ζ\zeta here plays the role that 1−γ−s1 - \gamma^{-s} played on the circle.

So the transform of every θ-function is zero at the zeros of ζ\zeta, whatever ff is. Because of the shift by ½, ρ\rho of ζ\zeta appears at s=ρ−12s = \rho - \tfrac12. If the holds these points are all on the imaginary axis, at s=±14.13i, ±21.02i, ±25.01i, …s = \pm 14.13i,\ \pm 21.02i,\ \pm 25.01i,\ \dots

Lab 13.1 the transform of Θ is zero at the zeros of ζ, for any f
f(x), the Θ(x) = √x · f(nx)
|M(f)(½ + iy)||M(Θ)(iy)|● zeros of zeta
the ratio |M(Θ)(iy)| / |M(f)(½ + iy)||ζ(½ + iy)|, computed independently
Top: ff is a bump minus a smaller bump, scaled so that ∫f dx=0\int f\,dx = 0 (the paper's condition for Θ\Theta to decay at both ends). Middle: the transform of Θ\Theta, computed by integrating the orange curve above, is zero at every dot for every ff. Bottom: the ratio of the two transforms equals ∣ζ(12+iy)∣|\zeta(\tfrac12 + iy)|. The two curves are computed independently and coincide.

Things to try

  • In Lab 13.1, move ff around and change its width. The blue transform changes shape completely; the orange one keeps its zeros at the same heights.
  • Look for a setting where the blue curve itself dips close to zero between two dots. The orange curve dips there as well, but the ratio in the bottom panel does not: it depends only on ζ\zeta. (Very close to such a dip the ratio is a of two tiny numbers and gets noisy.)

Exercises

  1. Show that the Mellin transform of f(nx)f(nx) is n−s⋅M(f)(s)n^{-s} \cdot M(f)(s).
    Solution

    Substitute u=nxu = nx: ∫0∞f(nx) xs dxx  =  ∫0∞f(u)(un)sduu  =  n−s⋅M(f)(s)\int_{0}^{\infty} f(nx)\,x^{s}\,\frac{dx}{x} \;=\; \int_{0}^{\infty} f(u)\left(\frac{u}{n}\right)^{s}\frac{du}{u} \;=\; n^{-s}\cdot M(f)(s) The measure dx/xdx/x is unchanged by rescaling.

  2. The first zero of ζ\zeta is ρ≈12+14.13i\rho \approx \tfrac12 + 14.13i. Where is the transform of Θf\Theta_f zero because of it?
    Solution

    At s=ρ−12≈14.13is = \rho - \tfrac12 \approx 14.13i, since M(Θf)(s)M(\Theta_f)(s) contains the factor ζ(s+12)\zeta(s + \tfrac12). That is the first dot in the lab.

  3. Why does Θf(x)\Theta_f(x) blow up as x→0x \to 0 unless ∫f dx=0\int f\,dx = 0?
    Solution

    For small xx the points nxnx are closely spaced, and x⋅∑f(nx)x \cdot \sum f(nx) is a sum for ∫f\int f. So ∑f(nx)≈1x∫f\sum f(nx) \approx \dfrac{1}{x} \int f, and Θf(x)≈x−1/2∫f\Theta_f(x) \approx x^{-1/2} \int f, which is unbounded unless the is 0.

Check your understanding

  1. The transform of Θf\Theta_f vanishes at s=ρ−12s = \rho - \tfrac12 for every zero ρ\rho, whichever ff you choose. What does that tell you?

    • That ff was chosen specially
    • The zeros are a property of summing over the whole numbers, not of ff
    • That Θf\Theta_f is identically 0

    M(Θf)(s)=ζ(s+12)⋅M(f)(s+12)M(\Theta_f)(s) = \zeta(s + \tfrac12) \cdot M(f)(s + \tfrac12). The factor ζ\zeta comes from ∑n−s\sum n^{-s} and is the same for every ff.

  2. What is the effect of the factor x\sqrt{x} in the definition of Θf\Theta_f?

    • It shifts ss by ½, so zeros on the critical line appear at purely imaginary ss
    • It makes the sum converge
    • It removes the zeros

    Multiplying by x1/2x^{1/2} shifts the Mellin variable by ½. The critical line Re⁡s=12\operatorname{Re} s = \tfrac12 becomes the imaginary axis, where the transform is an ordinary Fourier transform in ln⁡x\ln x.

  3. Suppose you summed f(nx)f(nx) over the odd nn only. Which factor would appear in front of M(f)M(f)?

    • ζ(s)+2−s\zeta(s) + 2^{-s}
    • ζ(2s)\zeta(2s)
    • ζ(s)⋅(1−2−s)\zeta(s) \cdot (1 - 2^{-s})

    The even nn contribute ∑(2m)−s=2−sζ(s)\sum (2m)^{-s} = 2^{-s}\zeta(s). Removing them leaves ζ(s)(1−2−s)\zeta(s)(1 - 2^{-s}): the Euler product without the factor for the prime 2.