Zeros as waves
The writes as minus one oscillating term for each zero of . A zero with contributes a term of size about , so the real parts of the zeros determine the size of .
The explicit formula
wrote down, and later proved, an exact equation between the of chapter 1 and the in the . It is called the explicit formula. Each zero is a , written :
Read it left to right. The first term, , is the smooth guess. Then comes one term for every zero. The last two terms are tiny corrections. So everything interesting is in the terms for the zeros.
Write a zero as . Then , and the zero together with its complex conjugate contributes a real oscillation:
- its frequency is : the oscillation is , periodic on a ;
- its amplitude is about , so it grows like and higher zeros contribute less.
What a zero off the line would do
If every zero is on the , , then every wave has amplitude about , and the total gap is about : the bound from chapter 1. A single zero with bigger than would contribute a wave of size , which eventually drowns out all the others. This is why the and the square-root bound on the gap are the same statement.
The mirror symmetry of chapter 7 matters here. A zero to the left of the line has a partner the same distance to the right, so any zero off the line produces a wave that grows faster than .
Things to try
- In Lab 8.1, set K = 1. The single wave already has a bump near every below 20.
- Slide the window to around 113. The flat stretch with no takes many zeros to flatten.
- In Lab 8.2, set . The growth is invisible at first and unmistakable by 10,000. This is why checking trillions of zeros by computer cannot settle the question.
Exercises
- Show that for .
Solution
and . Their sum is , because .
- By what factor must grow for the wave of the first zero () to complete one full oscillation?
Solution
repeats when increases by , that is, when is multiplied by .
- Two zeros have the same height, one with and one with . What is the ratio of their amplitudes at ?
Solution
. The ratio grows without bound as does.
Check your understanding
Why is "all zeros on the line " the best possible case for the size of the error?
- Because is the smallest real part a zero can have
- Because zeros come in mirror pairs and , so the largest real part is at least , with equality only if all are on the line
- Because waves with cancel each other
The error is as large as its largest wave, . A zero with forces a partner with , so nothing can beat .
Each wave is . How do its wiggles look near compared with near ?
- The same width
- Narrower
- A thousand times wider
The wave is periodic in : one cycle is a fixed ratio of (1.56 for the first zero). So the width in is proportional to . This is why the labs use a logarithmic axis.
What do the zeros at large height add to the reconstruction of the prime staircase?
- Fine detail: the sharpness of each individual jump
- The overall slope
- Nothing; only the first few zeros matter
A large is a high frequency. The first few zeros give the broad shape; resolving a single jump at a prime needs zeros with periods shorter than the gap between primes.